Skip to main content

Tactical Lessons From Mosul — Infantry Skills Matter

Tactical Lessons From Mosul — Infantry Skills Matter

Fight against ISIS has proceeded to the city of Mosul. Advance of the combined forces of Iraqi army, Kurdish Peshmergas and Shiite militias has grinded down to a near standstill as ISIS has fallen back and into the streets of Mosul. Why the coalition is unable to decisively crush the numerically inferior ISIS units defending the city?
ISIS tactics outside Mosul
While ISIS is often described as an insurgency, its tactics are actually a mix of conventional warfare and guerrilla tactics with a splash of extreme brutality and suicide attacks. When ISIS attacked Iraq, it used guerrilla cells set up in advance to cause chaos among the Iraqi security apparatus and then took over the territory with fast moving motorized units.
Now that the Islamic State has been pushed on the defense, it continues to use a very deadly mix of tactics. Some units continue to operate as terrorists cells, fading into the population and harassing the advancing Iraqi troops. Most forces have conducted somewhat effective delaying actions along the highways the attacking force is using.
The fortified area around Mosul can be divided into several rings. The outer settlements were manned by less reliable jihadists. ISIS allowed the attacking force to take them over, with relatively light resistance. IED, VBIED, ATGMs and sniper attacks were used sporadically to cause attrition to the Iraqi troops.
Emboldened by the early successes Iraqi forces entered the densely built areas.
Iraqi tactics
Iraqi army and the Shiite militias have mainly conducted limited scale operations than can be described as counter insurgency style operations. They have had at least limited control of the region. They have set up perimeters and control points with mechanized and motorized forces.
Enemy resistance was divided into smaller pockets by armored units and the pockets were either cleared out by the few elite units the Iraqi Army and Counter Terrorism Force have or they were sieged.
In support of these operations the Iraqi units ran protected Humvee convoys and vehicle patrols in order to disrupt and deter ISIS operations.
When these tactics were applied to the entrenched and well prepared ISIS units in Mosul the result was bloody. Iraqi army was forced to send its motorized light units in the streets of Mosul. ISIS then used pre-planned booby-traps and obstacles to funnel these Humvee convoys into kill zones where they were subjected to intense assaults by ISIS forces using IEDs, VBIEDs, RPGs and small arms fire.
After the failure of the light units the heavy armored units were sent in. The results were similar, with several tanks getting knocked out in single ambushes. As a commander of an Iraqi tank unit stated, his men were not trained on fighting in urban conditions and lacked any organic infantry components.
Combined arms co-operation is poor among the Iraqi and Shiite unites. This results in operations that the motivated and prepared ISIS forces can easily repel. ISIS then launches relentless waves of counter attacks with platoon — company sized units that contain few suicide bombers and some sappers. These assault units are well motivated and some of them seem to be well trained in infantry cqb-tactics.
Conclusions
Iraqi Army has found its very own Stalingrad, where they are able take some ground with armor support, but are unable to hold it against enemy counter attacks that ISIS is able to conduct on their own terms.
Close quarters battle from house to house and room to room against an opponent is grueling and the lack of success is demoralizing. Iraqi Army does not possess the skills or motivation required to successfully defeat ISIS in infantry warfare.
What every military on the planet should learn here is, that you cannot overestimate the importance of small unit infantry tactics, the skills of the individual soldiers, a proper motivation and high morale.
If an army lacks those skills, it’s forced to choose either to siege indefinitely or destroy the entire urban are with indirect fire, like Russia did in Grozny and Assad is doing in Aleppo.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Two new divisions for the Russian army

Latest news is that Russia will expand both of the remaining motorized rifle brigades of the 58th Combined Arms Army into full strength divisions. This would mean that the army would have three full divisions of mechanized forces with heavy artillery and missile support. At the same time when the brigades are being upgraded, “Other units of the 58th Army” will be moved from their traditional posts in the Northern Caucasus further into west.

There is no schedule for the transition, but as Chechnya is relatively calm under the iron grip of Kremlins pet attack dog Kadyrov, the already full strength 42nd Motorized Rifle Division, that was expanded in 2016, could begin its relocation at a moments notice.
Not that long ago the Russian armed forces transited largely to a brigade structure, very similar to that of the western armies. Next iteration of this concept were the Battalion Tactical Groups that are agile independent units, with integral indirect fire components and high operational …

A Piece of our family history: the Battle of Petäjäsaari 1940.

As a celebration of the #Finland100 I decided to write about a small but personal piece of Finnish history. A few years ago my mother asked me to find out what exactly happened to her uncle Sulo, who had disappeared during the Second World War. She knew that it had happened at the end of the Winter War in 1940, but nothing else. She gave me his full name, rough time of birth and a copy of his last letter. In that letter he wrote that he had just arrived as fresh reinforcement to a new unit.



Armed with this information I started to dig some archives and uncovered the date of Sulo's demise, only three days after the last letter was dated. The same source revealed the unit he had served in and the place of his disappearance.
Another archive hosted the war diaries of the different Finnish military units, so I dug out the diary of the 6th company of the 35th infantry regiment, that  Sulo had served in. On the very day my great uncles last letter was dated, there is actually a mention …

9000 Tons of Steel: Russian Tank Drills in the Urals

After a flurry of rather disinformative “Tank Carousel” news from Russia the latest reportage from the Russian armed force tank exercise is much more interesting. At the beginning of August the handily named 90th Guards Vitebsk-Novgorod twice Red Banner Tank Division held it’s first divisional sized combat and live fire exercise at Cherbakul in the Chelyabinsk region.
The 90th division, that is stationed in the Sverdlovsk and Chelyabinsk regions, was founded in 2016 and is one of the heaviest hitting Russian formations around. It has a similar structure as the 4th Kantemirovskaya Tank Division that is part of the 1st Guards Tank Army.
The 90th Tank Division consists of the following units: •Headquarters •6th Guards Lvov Tank Regiment  •80th Tank Regiment •239th Guards Tank Regiment •228th Motorized Rifle Regiment •400th Transylvania Self-Propelled Artillery Regiment  •Anti-Aircraft Regiment •30th Separate Reconnaissance Battalion •351st Separate Engineer Sapper Battalion •33rd Separa…